Philosophies of punishment

A poor ex-student, he responds to his poverty not by taking from others but by working even harder. Compromise Theories Many theorists have attempted to take features of utilitarianism and retributivism and combine them into a theory that retains the strengths of both while overcoming their weaknesses.

The stance in question is openness to the provisional validity of a core set of Hindu texts. Since well confirmed generalizations are more reliable than hunches, happiness is most likely to be maximized when individuals give the vast majority of the weight to such well confirmed generalizations when making moral decisions.

The reasoning is simple when viewed through the lens of retributive theory. Since the early 20th century, basic education of criminal justice personnel has primarily focused on developing the skills necessary to be effective in the field.

Foucault invited us to view the practice of punishment under law as subject to general forces in society that reflect the dominant forms of social and political power—the power to threaten, coerce, suppress, destroy, transform—that prevail in any given epoch.

But surely making an example of the one thief who was unlucky or unskilled enough to be caught is unjust. Those laws signaled the end of private justice achieved through blood feuds by confirming compensation as the accepted method of justice in ancient Rome.

Nevertheless, punishment retains some retributive elements, conceptually and normatively. Under retributive justice schemes, it is also important that offenders actually be guilty of the crime for which a penalty has been imposed.

Finally, although the practice of punishment under law may be the very perfection of punishment in human experience, most of us learn about punishment well before any encounters with the law. Deprivation has no covert or subjective reference; punishment is an objectively judged loss or burden imposed on a convicted offender.

Once we do this, it supposedly becomes clear that the utilitarian is not committed to performing this clearly wrong act. Punishment—especially punishment under law, by officers of the government—is as noted above a human institution, not a natural fact.

Organizational justice is viewed as a philosophical approach to provide the following: Varna Caste Finally, one might attempt to identify Hinduism with the institution of a caste system that carves society into a specified set of classes whose natures dispose them and obligate them to certain occupations in life.

In this world, a Kantian would be committed to the position that punishments still ought to be inflicted upon wrongdoers. However, it is not true that all Hindus are polytheists. Non-systematic Hindu philosophy is comprised of the philosophical elements of the primary and secondary bodies of canonical Hindu texts, while the systematic Hindu philosophies, which also adopt the congenial disposition towards the Vedas, find their definitive expressions in formal philosophical texts authored by professional philosophers.

They lack as well the opportunity and time to secure such information and to use it to inform their sentences.


Political Principles and Community Values, London: This is usually argued for along Kantian lines: Technically competent people 2. Prima facie, the bronze quality appears to correspond to tamas, silver to rajas, and sattva to gold.

Essays in the Philosophy of Law, Oxford: The first model required all police recruits to attend two semesters at a local college prior to attending the police academy; the second model was college attendance after the academy.

University of Chicago Law School. New Introductory Essays in Moral Philosophy. Section 7 of the Education Act covering England and Wales states that parents have a duty to cause their children to receive an efficient education suitable to age, ability and aptitude and any special needs.

While retributivists seem to have an easier time ensuring that there be a direct relationship between the amount of punishment and the seriousness of the offense, their position is subject to criticism.

Punishment - Theories Of Punishment

Kant would not agree that this consequence of his theory is odd. We could identify Hinduism as the set of religious views that recognize the divinity or exalted status of a core set of Indic deities, but this too would not provide a way to separate Hinduism from Buddhism and Jainism.

Buddhism and Jainism were both critical of the practice. What justifies the general practice of punishment? It lacks the ability to be an agent.Introduction Knowledge.


Traditionally, the term "philosophy" referred to any body of knowledge. In this sense, philosophy is closely related to religion, mathematics, natural science, education and politics. Crime & Punishment - The Complete Miniseries: Carinthia West, David Dodimead, Tim Brown, Francesca Gerrard, Yvonne Coulette, Geoffrey Drew, Gertan Klauber.

Discussion of sentencing and corrections in the 21st century must begin with a review of these changes and their impact on the criminal justice At the same time the goals of punishment have been changing, the number of people in the United States who are under correctional supervision has increased enormously.

Changes in the practice and. A punishment is the imposition of an undesirable or unpleasant outcome upon a group or individual, meted out by an authority—in contexts ranging from child discipline to criminal law—as a response and deterrent to a particular action or behaviour that is deemed undesirable or unacceptable.

The reasoning may be to condition a child to avoid self-endangerment, to impose social conformity (in. The four Philosophies of Punishment (1) Retribution: It is a hypothesis of equity that considers proportionate punishment an adequate reaction to wrongdoing.

This retribution theory essentially fit the ethical gravity of a wrongdoing committed and, to a lesser degree, the qualities of the guilty party. The five philosophies of punishment include retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation, and restitution.

Retribution is the best at exemplifying the philosophy of punishment.

Hell: Origins of an Idea

Early ideas of punishment included torture, beatings, branding, exile and death.

Philosophies of punishment
Rated 3/5 based on 68 review